Through Quirk, I got a lot of chances to meet other folks in the space are building and to gather some advice from those who've done well and those who've done poorly. The following is a summation of that advice.
If your product concept starts with "why is there no easy way to do X?" there's a reasonable chance you're looking at an invisible crowded space.
An invisible crowded space is a product area that lots of people want to make, but the concept is bad and nearly every single product fails. Because every product does so poorly, you probably haven't heard of any of them, even if you consider yourself familiar with the subject matter.
That leads to two types of biases that convince people to add bad products to a failing space:
A good example of a common invisible crowded space is mental health journaling.
There are literally thousands of apps out there, tons that are just FAR better than what 99% of people could create.
Take Jour. I would argue Jour is the top of the market here. It's absolutely gorgeous and it's great to use, but any attempt to market it has fallen flat. This isn't for lack of trying, they had a pretty good product hunt launch that was upvoted by the folks that make product hunt!
My best guess is that Jour has maybe about 5k to 25k total downloads with a daily active user base of about 100 to 500. These are super respectable numbers but likely not what the original creators were hoping for given the clear effort put into the product.
Mental health journaling is really difficult to get anyone to do. The people who would most benefit from the practice are the least likely to do it! Plus, getting people to do something daily is a notoriously difficult problem! Even more so, anyone who likes journaling will just use a non-MH specific journaling tool.
If you're building in a space that's invisible to you, can you beat the Jours of that space? If Jour can't succeed in this space, what value are you providing?
Mental health consumer tech products suffer from leaky user engagement much more so than other industries.
It's often very difficult to get someone going through something to try new tools or treatments. Professional treatment can mitigate this; people are much more likely to do something if their therapist tells them.
But often the people who could most benefit from your product are the least likely to find or use it.
Some budding product people try to solve this problem with pretty sketch engagement mechanics.
If your product is any variant of: "If the user records a thought, we'll donate to Oxfam" or another "good action," then take a step back.
You may convince yourself your solving for two problems at once; that this is the moral way of helping people.
But it's ignorant of how people work. People don't like doing things or changing their habits. Using your product is changing their daily routine. By itself, that's hard.
Because it's hard, many users will fail. When they do, what will they think?
If you're using guilt as an engagement mechanic, you've implicitly told them that failure to use your product is not only their fault, but that it has serious consequences.
If you're giving food to a starving child for every week the user pokes at your app; then you've heightened the stakes for a game users are destined to fail.
Guilt can come in a lot of forms. When you see it, be skeptical:
If you're recording someone's thoughts, their mood over time, or their meetings with therapists, you're storing some of the most sensitive data a user can have.
Most people would rather give you their password than their Cognitive Behavioral Therapy thoughts. They're often the most embarrassing thing in someone's life. They contain sensitive details about other people. By definition, they are the source of shame, anxiety, fear, and depression.
They also are prime targets for blackmail, abusive spouses, targeted defamation, and revenge.
Often budding product people will think that because they're doing something "good" with the information, they're absolved from the effort required to protect their information.
Be skeptical of products that:
If this sort of thing interests you and you live in the bay area, let's grab coffee sometime! Shoot me an email:
coffee @ econn.dev